Best Neighborhoods in Key West (2026)

The most loved neighborhoods in Key West — ranked on a mix of walkability, things to do, and overall traveler appeal.

  1. Old Town–Duval Street

    Historic cottages and lively bars.

    Old Town–Duval Street is a base for visiting Ernest Hemingway Home around Key West. Stay for walkable nightlife and museums. Crowds peak around evening bars.

    Nightlife, First-timers

  2. Historic Seaport

    Working harbor and waterfront restaurants.

    Historic Seaport is a base for visiting Key West Historic Seaport around Key West. Choose boating excursions and sunset activity. Boardwalks can be wet and crowded.

    Ferries, Foodies

  3. Bahama Village

    Residential blocks near Fort Zachary Taylor.

    Bahama Village is a base for visiting Bahama Village around Key West. Good for local food and quieter Old Town streets. Evening streets are less busy than Duval.

    Culture, Quiet

  4. New Town

    Practical hotels and shopping east of Old Town.

    New Town is a base for visiting Smathers Beach around Key West. Useful for airport access and family trips. A bus or bike is needed for Old Town attractions.

    Families, Transit